Episode Transcript
[00:00:00] Josh Bowman: Hello everyone. Welcome to another episode of Cicero. On Duties, we are reading Cicero's magnum opus, the Deifice, and we're reading through the Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought. I'm Josh Bowman, executive director of the Ciceronean Society that produces this podcast. I'm joined by Chris Anadale, professor of Philosophy at Mount St. Mary's University, and Catherine Bradshaw, who is a Latin and Greek fellow at the Ancient Language Institute. We're so glad you're here. There's a lot more to the Ciceronean Society. If you don't know, please sign up for our newsletter Take a look at two upcoming events one January 23rd at Colloquium on Uncivil Discourse in Scottsdale, Arizona. Registration for that is now open. We also have our spring conference March 11th through the 13th in Virginia Beach, Virginia. Lots going on additional podcasts and we actually we're almost at the end of De Officis and and so what do you want us to read next? What do you want to talk about next?
We'd love to keep going with some some Cicero, but please, you know, let us know if there's other books you'd like us to look at and read.
These great texts in the history of Western thought are often best when we read them in community. And yeah, you can't always interact with us directly, although you can in the comments.
I hope that our little community that we share with you on a weekly basis has been beneficial to your own reading and to your own thinking as you encounter these texts.
We're going to start today with chapter 50 in book three of Deificis. Catherine will begin reading that, and we'll go from there. So without further ado, Katherine, take it away.
[00:01:43] Katherine Bradshaw: All right.
Cases often do arise, however, as I have said already, where benefit seems to conflict with honorableness, then one must examine whether it clearly conflicts, or whether it could be combined with what is honorable. The following are questions of this type. For example, suppose that a good man had brought a large quantity of corn from Alexandria to Rhodes at a time when corn was extremely expensive among the Rhodians because of shortage and famine. If he also knew that several more merchants had set sail from Alexandria and had seen their boats en route, laden with corn and heading for Rhodes. Would he tell the Rhodians, or would he keep silent and sell his own produce at as high a price as possible? We are imagining that he is a wise and good man. Our question is about the deliberations and considerations of a man who would not conceal the facts from the Rhodians, if he judged it dishonorable, but is uncertain as to whether it is dishonorable in cases of this type. Diogenes of Babylon, a great and respected Stoic, tended to have one view, his pupil Antipater, an extremely intelligent man. Another Antipater thought that everything should be disclosed, so that there was nothing at all that the seller knew and the buyer did not know. To Diogenes it seemed that the seller ought to mention such faults as the civil law requires, and to do everything else without trickery. But since he is selling, he ought to want to sell at the best price. I have transported this here, I have offered it for sale, and. And I sell it for no more than others do, perhaps even for less. When the supply is more plentiful, who is treated unjustly? On the other side, Antipater's argument is put forward. What are you saying? You ought to be considering the interests of men and serving human fellowship.
You were born under a law, and you have principles of nature which you ought to obey and follow to the effect that your benefit is the common benefit, and conversely, the common benefit is yours. Will you conceal from men the advantages and resources that are available to him?
Diogenes will perhaps reply, to conceal is one thing, to keep silent another. I am not at the present moment concealing from you the nature of the gods or the end of good things, if I am not telling you of it, to learn yet to learn that would benefit you far more than to learn the cheap price of wheat. But it is not necessary for me to tell you everything that is beneficial for you to hear.
[00:04:11] Chris Anadale: This is a fantastic example, of course, one that the economists among our friends will seize upon. Is one permitted to profit from the asymmetry of knowledge. If I happen to know that the price will shortly fall. Need I tell you, if you are my friend, I might say that I have a sort of duty of friendship, as we were talking about in the last episode, to tell you. But if I'm just engaging in a commercial transaction with you, we have this dispute. Well, is it dishonorable for me to remain silent? Is that the equivalent, we might say, of lying? Of causing you to act upon a false belief which I know to be false and could easily correct? And so we're not quite all the way through the dispute about this, which ends in chapter 53?
But I'll tell you, actually, I'm going to do something different here. Let me just read 53 to finish this line of reasoning and then turn it over to Josh And Catherine, to continue commenting on.
So, picking up where you left off, Catherine, but no, he will answer. It is necessary if indeed you remember that men are bound together in fellowship by nature.
I remember. The other will argue, but is that fellowship of a kind, that nothing belongs to any one person? If that is so, then nothing can be sold at all, but must be given.
You will see that in the whole of this debate, the following is never said. Although this is dishonorable, however, I will do it, for it is expedient. But rather, it is expedient in such a way that it is not dishonorable. On the other side, again, it should not be done for the very reason that it is dishonorable.
Josh,
[00:05:50] Josh Bowman: you know, this. This is where, you know, the whole time I'm reading this, I'm thinking of. Of selling a house, right? So every house has its issues.
And, you know, there's things that you, you know, if you're just looking at a house, you don't know, right. Everything that's wrong, or if you're the buyer. Do I have a moral obligation as part of the same society as the person I'm buying this house? No, the person I'm selling this house to. To convey all the issues with this house. Everywhere that there's a leak, everywhere that there's a crack, everywhere that there's, you know, this light switch only works when it feels like it. You know, there's those kinds of things.
Or like, hey, yeah, that's where the mice come in, right? Those.
That's all that information.
I'm not lying.
Right.
And I think there's.
There's something to this. I mean, of course, you know, I could share all the information that I have with said buyer and something would go wrong. Right? That's just how homeownership is. But, you know, I think there is. There's an element of, you know, how.
How far do we have to go with this on the economic side? He brings it into economics.
Do the calculations change here?
You know, do. And I think there's also. But there's. There's another element here that I think economists would latch onto in the sense that trust is also really important.
I don't think he uses that word, but it's kind of in the background where if you're constantly engaging in economic transactions in a way that is beneficial but dishonorable, you're breaking down trusts, the trust that holds a free market together. Now, of course, he's not speaking the language of a free market, but he does understand that for an Economy to work, you have to have a certain level of trust in there that the value has to be what it is.
Of course, this is going to be significant for Rome as time goes on, because they're going to devalue their currency so significantly.
Their currency is going to be so, by the end, almost worthless in a sense. Right. They keep making more of it, but it's mingled with stuff that couldn't even be considered currency in any meaningful sense.
So I think this is an interesting point here.
I don't know, you know, from a Christian perspective, how do we, how do we deal with this, you know, that asymmetry of knowledge. Do we always have to fix it before we engage in an economic transaction?
There are better scholars for that question. I am not the one, but I think it is an interesting, an interesting dilemma that when we are.
This is actually part of why I'm not in sales, because I could not sell something that I think is a piece of crap.
I, I know other people, they, they could sell, they could sell you a pencil with no, let, you know, a elect a, a pencil with no lead in it, right? A mechanical pencil with no lead in it to people, and they could probably get you to buy it. Like, that's, on the one hand, I respect that. There's, there's a gift of persuasion that is so powerful. On the other hand, what are you doing?
It's, it is, or, or, you know, car salesmen, right, they can sell this car. They know it's going to break down, you know, when, when you leave the, the stinking parking lot and they're able to do it. You know, I, I, I have a, you know, it seems dishonorable, but at the same time, you know, hey, they fooled you. You know, it's your money, is it? This just how you do, you have to just live with it, right? Lemon laws, I hear, I heard recently, by the way.
So we know about lemon laws when it comes to cars. Did you know there are lemon laws in some states, maybe all states, when it comes to pets, there are pet lemon laws.
I was, I was last week years old when I learned that.
Make of that what you will. Going on to Catherine, then to comment on this.
[00:09:55] Katherine Bradshaw: This is, this is, I mean, Cicero admits that this is a sticky issue. That's, we have now come to the sticky issues part of the treatise.
And, and Josh, he's going to get to property in a second. So that's, that's definitely top of his mind too.
And it's interesting because in the 4th century A.D. st. Ambrose of Milan. So the. The guy who was very instrumental in leading St. Augustine of Hippo to the Lord wrote a treatise called De Officiis and it is basically the Christian version of what we're reading now.
And so he would say, yeah, if I remember correctly, that of course, oh, grain merchant, you should tell the Rodians that there are other grain merchants behind you.
I think for Cicero, at least in this example and going forward a bit too, it's not that one has to reveal everything, it's that what are, what is the person playing on in the concealment?
Like, is this, is. Is this a question of I'm playing on your need or your ignorance or your something in order to gain advantage? Am I manipulating you basically, or am I being as honest as I possibly can? And maybe I'm not telling you every single thing because I don't know every single thing, but if I, or I assume that you already know, that's going to come up later.
But if it's a I am intention intentionally, excuse me, manipulating or twisting or changing or shading the circumstances for my own benefit.
And this gets back to why does the, you know, why is it wrong to take the cloak from a tyrant?
Well, no, if you're doing it for the right reasons, in the right way, at the right time, etc. Etc. Etc. So this is back to the Aristotelian view of prudence and virtue being necessary for decisions like this, where you're not quite sure what is the honorable thing to do.
[00:12:19] Chris Anadale: Okay, I think I'll take the next reading.
That's chapters 54 and 55 for Josh to comment on. And let's go look at the real estate example. Now, I think.
Suppose that a good man is selling his house because of certain faults that he knows and that others do not know. Say that it is unsanitary but thought to be salubrious, or that it is not generally known that vermin can be found in all the bedrooms, or that it is structurally unsound and crumbling, but no one except the owner knows this.
My question is this. If the seller does not tell the buyers these things, but sells the house at a higher price than that at which he thought he would sell it, will he not have acted unjustly and dishonestly?
He will indeed antipater claims give me an instance of failing to show the path to someone who is lost, something which is prohibited in Athens on pain of a public curse.
If it is not this, allowing a buyer to rush into a deal in succumb through his Error to being thoroughly deceived. Indeed, it is more than failing to show the path. Rather, it is knowingly to lead someone into error.
And Diogenes, again, if someone has not even encouraged you to buy, surely he hasn't forced you. He advertised something that he didn't want and you bought something that you did want. If those who advertise a villa as good and built well are not thought to have deceived you, even though it is neither good nor methodically built, then it's much less the case for those who haven't praised their house.
Where is it up to the buyer to judge?
Where it is up to the buyer to judge. How can there be deceit on the part of the seller? Indeed, if one need not accept responsibility for everything that was actually stated, do you really think that one need do so for something that was not stated?
What is more foolish than for a seller to recount the faults of the very thing he is selling? What could be more absurd than for the auctioneer to say, I am selling an unsanitary house?
[00:14:35] Josh Bowman: First of all, I just want to make a point of saying, you can tell I didn't read ahead, dear viewer. So when I gave my example, I had no idea it was coming in the next chapter. So there's that. I do think we underused the word salubrious.
So I need to find multiple ways to use the word salubrious in a sentence this week.
But, yeah, I mean, part, part of my, my dilemma here is I've already given, I've already kind of given my commentary here. But I also think that there's other ways that this, you know, this might apply in the sense of, you know, student loans, for example, or.
Well, yeah, you mean education itself. You know, one of the things that's also is that it's. We're offering, we're making promises that we can't keep, or we are valuing something, we are pricing something in a way that is not consistent with the information. Right. I mean, this is one. Economists are big on this. Right? Price is. You're telling a story with that price on both sides of the seller and the buyer.
The price is not simply, you know, this is how much profit I want. And therefore, you know, there's a lot of information involved in setting that price. And so to what extent do you have to share? I also like the fact that he's.
It's almost like Cicero wants to break into dialogue any minute. Right? He's written dialogues before this. He really wants to do a dialogue between Antipater and Diogenes and he's just like, no, I'm not going to do it. I feel like I'm about to do it. No, I'm not going to do it. I'm just not. But I also, I think that, that, that commends him. I think he, he, in many ways the Greeks that he reveres so much, especially Plato, understands this, the format of the dialogue there, there's something very attractive to that. And so he, he feels like that's actually the best way to get at this. He's not going full dialogue, but he's, he's almost getting there. So I, I, I think that's interesting. Now I, I use the example of student loans because there's no way that's coming up next. But we'll see, we'll see what happens. But yeah, Catherine,
[00:16:51] Katherine Bradshaw: yeah, this is it. But it is the quintessential example for, for housing, housing being the selling of property being the quintessential example. I do, I do love, you do get a good sense of Roman kind of real estate culture through this because it's, it's not just that like there's a leak in the roof or something. It's that there are vermin in all of the bedrooms or something like that. It's, it's, it's an ancient, it's a problem when you don't have the ability to like fully insulate your house type of things.
And, and there is, this is a push pull thing because it does seem ridiculous to say pestilential house for sale, which is like the very literal translation of what the Latin says.
We all go, we all, we all laugh at that because it's so absurd.
But at the same time, if we're going with Antipater, then why is that absurd? Oh, it's absurd because we expect people to use what legally is called puffery in their advertising. We expect people to lie to us in their advertising good and well built house when it is neither good nor well built.
And this is something actually that we're running into a lot lately because there's a lot of new construction that they find mold, like black mold in the houses and they're brand new, but they were badly built and so now the owners can't live in them and they're the first people to own the house.
And I think this gets to the breakdown of trust that both of you were talking about earlier. Our housing market is now becoming Roman to an, to an extent.
And I think this is, this is a place where Cicero is being kind of countercultural here, because in the ancient world, you expected to be cheated a lot of times when you went to the market. There's no such thing as price tags. They don't do that. You haggle over everything, and you expect the merchant to put sand in your bread.
Unless you're, like, way, way, way up on the economic scale, that kind of thing.
[00:19:02] Chris Anadale: Yeah. It certainly seems that dishonesty in real estate deals goes back, you know, millennia, that everybody. I feel for, you know, for poor Josh here, but obviously Cicero obviously knew all about this, about liars, loans and about the cheating, and everybody lies in real estate. That. That is the kind of market that we do seem to have. Now, it seems to me that part of what we're discussing here is the boundary between friendship, your friend, and I'm selling you something. I owe it to you in friendship to give you the information that I have to treat you as I would expect you, my friend, to treat me. But if I'm engaging in a commercial transaction with you, we're not friends. I'm not going to ever see you again. Perhaps if I've just come to Rhodes especially to sell my grain this one time.
What do I owe to you as a fellow human being, if not necessarily as a fellow citizen or as a close friend?
How far does this extend? Am I concealing something if I merely omit to men? Mention it? That was part of the argument. I'm not telling you the truth about human nature and about virtue and happiness, which would be far more beneficial. You don't blame me for concealing that from you? I'm not concealing it if I don't tell it to you.
So we're still sort of dancing back and forth in this kind of. Not quite a dialogue between things being said on both sides, and I think we'll come to the conclusion of that quite soon.
Josh. The next reading, I think, is chapters 56 and 57. Would you read those, please, for Catherine to comment on?
[00:20:31] Josh Bowman: Of course.
In certain doubtful cases, therefore, honorableness is thus defended on one side, while on the other, they argue the case for benefit, but in such a way that it turns out not only to be honorable to do whatever seems beneficial, but even dishonorable, not to do it.
This is the kind of incompatibility that seems to arise between the beneficial and the honorable. And such cases must be adjudicated, for we did not set them out in order to ask questions, but in order to explicate them. Well, then it seems that the corn dealer ought not to have concealed anything from the Rhodians, nor the seller of the house from its buyers. For it is not concealment to be silent about anything, but when you want those in whose interest it would be to know something that you know, to remain ignorant of it so that you may profit.
Who cannot see what this kind of concealment is like and what sort of man practices it?
Certainly not one who is open, straightforward, well bred, just or good, but rather a twister, mysterious, cunning, tricky, ill intentioned, crafty, roguish and sly. Surely it is not beneficial to subject oneself to all these allegations of viciousness and many others.
[00:21:46] Katherine Bradshaw: Cicero and his lists, this is one of his favorite rhetorical techniques, is to stack things on top of each other and overwhelm you with all of these things.
And okay, so he lands mostly on the side of Antipater, and it again would be very countercultural for him to do so.
This is, this is not the culture he's living in. It's. It's a culture that the first century Romans would recognize as very old Roman, the type of, like Cato the Elder that. That sort of old Roman who thinks, no, no, no, this is straightforward. This is not a thing that I should really be deliberating about too much.
I should be straightforward. I should be a person that is trustworthy. I should be a person who is all of the, all of the adjectives that he uses, candid, sincere, all of these things.
That's what I should be. And therefore I'm going to do the things that would be that, even though it may seem less beneficial for me, because in the long run it will be more beneficial for me to be virtuous than not.
But this is not what happens in his day. He offers many examples, not just Caesar, but later we're going to talk about Hortensius and Crassus and other. I mean, he's mentioned Crassus and Hortensius before, but all of these people, some of whom are good men by the standards of first century Rome, who do shifty things because it seems beneficial and it's just normal. And so Cicero is taking a stance that's very different from those around him.
[00:23:33] Chris Anadale: I think here in this chapters we finally get the answer. The Cicero's answer and Antipater's mostly right.
We've given them both sort of fair play and we've sort of seen the logic and the reasoning behind them. But the conclusion here is that a good man would tell about the grain shifts, a good house seller would tell about the vermin in the bedrooms.
But it seems to be because it will be dishonorable if my intention in concealing or in just remaining silent is to make more money at your expense. I'm thinking sort of craftily to myself, I will omit to mention the vermin in every bedroom, and therefore you will give me more money. Ha ha, ha, ha. And there's something just sort of low and bas this. It's contrary to honor, it's contrary to human fellowship, and people are justly angry with me. They justly criticize me when this is the way I treat my fellow human beings. So this is a case where it's my duty to be noble this time and to say, yeah, actually, the house is kind of crap, so you ought to pay me less for it, and I suffer less money. But what is money compared to honor? And that seems to be Cicero's final solution to this, Having considered both sides and given us the Diogenes argument in favor of let the buyer beware.
Josh?
[00:24:50] Josh Bowman: Yeah.
I'm going to ask a question, especially to Catherine, and I'm going to cede my time to her answer, but because so much of honorableness has to do with the culture in which the action is taking place.
And so you're saying that Cicero is acting counterculturally.
How recognizable might that be to the Roman. Well, you know, here's what I mean by that, because on the one hand, I think we can recognize as a sinful person who at least understands what virtue is.
I see the Antipater is right to a point, or at least just seems more. Honor certainly seems more honorable in my context.
But would they even recognize that in Cicero's day? Because I could see, you know, could a society become so decadent in a way that they don't even recognize this dispute? Right. They're all with Diogenes here, and they don't even know why we're even talking to Antipater.
[00:25:59] Katherine Bradshaw: Yeah, that's a really good point, Josh.
And the ancients recognize that that's possible.
Thucydides very famously talks about his.
His Athens had become so corrupt that those who did the honorable thing, those who followed this advice that Cicero later, you know, will give, are considered fools who just do stupid things because they don't know any better. Like they're naive and. And targets for being taken advantage of.
I think that Cicero feels.
I think Cicero's Rome has fallen quite a bit, but it is not quite that far, at least amongst the kind of philosophically inclined Romans.
So would the average person think this?
Not sure. Probably they would recognize that that's a countercultural thing, and they wouldn't dismiss it out of hand.
You do see the kind of common people's reactions to certain later emperors who are particularly decadent, which is very negative. And so I think that Rome has not fallen to the point of classical Athens in that regard. But at the same time, there is a contrast. And this is something that comes up in a lot of Cicero's treatises that are dialogues, that are phrased as dialogues, that people will praise somebody for doing something that is different from what is common. And so I think the contrast is shown now. Yes, this is Cicero talking, but he's writing for Roman readers. And so in that case, he must assume that his audience is going to know this. You see this later with the. With Augustus trying to do all those moral reforms not long after this, where obviously that's countercultural, but the. Everyone recognized it, which is why it was a big deal.
[00:28:04] Chris Anadale: Okay, if we have time to wrap us up, Catherine, I'd like you to read chapters 58 through 60, a long example again about real estate, and we'll conclude this episode, please.
[00:28:14] Katherine Bradshaw: Certainly.
Furthermore, if those who kept quiet are to be denounced, what are we to think of those who actually told lies as well? Gaius Canius, a Roman eques, who was not without wit and fairly well read, went off to Syracuse for leisure, as he often put it himself, and not for business. There he used to say repeatedly that he wanted to buy some grounds where he could invite his friends and enjoy himself without people interrupting him. This became widely known, and a certain Pythias, who ran a banking house in Syracuse, said that he had some grounds which were not for sale, but which, if Canius might, which Canius might, if he wished, use as his own. At the same time, he invited him to dine in these grounds. On the following day, When Canius accepted, Pittheus, who as a banker could command the gratitude of men of every order, called some fishermen together to him and asked them if on the next day they would fish in front of his grounds, explaining what he wanted them to do.
Canius arrived in time for the meal, and Pittheus had had a sumptuous spread prepared. Before their eyes was a huge number of boats, and each man in turn brought in what he had caught. The fish were laid at Pythias feet. Then Canius said, what is this, Pythias? So many fish, so many boats, he replied, it's not surprising, for this is where all the fish in Syracuse are. Water is also drawn from here. They cannot do without this estate.
Canius was inflamed with greed and urged Pittheus to sell the place. At first he responded reluctantly, but what more need I say, Canius succeeded. He was rich and he was greedy for it, and he paid as much as Pittheus wanted, including in his purchase all the fittings. Pittheus entered it in his account book and completed the business on the following day. Canius invited his friends and arrived early himself. There was not a rowlock in sight.
He asked his nearest neighbor whether the fishermen were on holiday, as he could not see any.
Not as far as I know, he replied, but there aren't usually any fishermen here. That's why I was wondering what happened yesterday.
Canius was furious, but what could he do for my colleague and friend Gaius Aquilius had not yet introduced his rules of procedure concerning malicious fraud on this question. When he was asked what malicious fraud was, he used to reply, when one thing is pretended and another is done, that is finely put, as one might expect from a man experienced in giving definitions, both Pythias, therefore, and everyone else who does one thing and pretends another is treacherous, dishonest and ill intentioned. No action of that sort can be beneficial, imbued as it is with so many vices.
[00:31:03] Chris Anadale: I love this story, and not only because it's a long and amusing story about, you know, a greedy man being taken advantage of by another unscrupulous man. It's got a sort of, sort of proverb or fable like quality to it, but also because it involves this shift. Cicero says, well, this is how we judge the close call, which is somebody knows something but opts to conceal it, or at least to be silent about it, about the problems with the house, about the coming drop in grain prices in order to profit. Well, what about a man who tells a straight up lie and he tells this story, I think in part just because it's an amusing story to illustrate the point, but to drive home again his lesson at the end. He always ends with the lesson, no action of this sort, treacherous, dishonest, et cetera, can be beneficial. You think it's beneficial? It is not. It is dishonorable. And being dishonorable, it fails to be beneficial. Even if the seller has managed to trick this, this other fellow into. Into giving him more money for it, so that the benefit here is not to be accounted. Josh,
[00:32:17] Josh Bowman: you know, I wonder. That's just a great story. And I wonder if, you know, would Cicero just be against the whole idea of marketing?
Is all marketing just lying well, or overstating everything, right? If you. If you purchase this, you won't just have this thing. You will have an experience. It will change your life. You will have this experience. Right?
Now, I remember as a. As a teenager, you know, the commercials for Axe, right? The hair gel and the deodorant. Supposedly, if I apply this to my person, women would fawn upon my. Upon my me. It didn't work. I didn't work at all. And I still haven't heard back on that lawsuit. But, you know, there is something to this where Cicero's just like, we need to have trust for this economy to work or for the res publica to work. And if we have a bunch of Pythiases, I don't know that's the right plural Pythia, then what are we going to. You know, who are we going to become?
And at the same time, I can't help but laugh. I mean, both of these men are greedy, and they're just playing off one another.
And the whole thing with the fishermen is just brilliant. Like, how did.
Like this. This is the best fishing spot in the whole. In the whole place. That. I mean, that would have worked on me, frankly, as a fisherman myself. That would have been like, well, okay, I think I need to live here. Not only is it beautiful and it's a great space, but.
Yeah. And I. The.
The fact that he, at one point, Pythias changes the contract, Right. First it's in good faith, it's an oral agreement, and then it becomes a written one. Right? I mean, Kanye has a chance to. To get out of this. He doesn't. His greed. His greed gets the better of him. He does. He does what seems beneficial and pays for it, literally and figuratively.
[00:34:23] Katherine Bradshaw: Yes. That is.
It's. It's one of those stories where you go, nobody's. Nobody's the good guy in this story. And we all just enjoy it because it's a bunch of bad guys doing things to each other.
But at the same time, it is, as you all already mentioned, it is a more obvious case than the earlier ones.
And so it is interesting to me that the Cicero then turns to definitions where he says, like, okay, now we have to define what malicious fraud is in and of itself.
And it's such a simple definition.
You know, saying one thing and doing another, and it sounds too simple almost.
It sounds like, well, but in that case, no one will ever sell anything, ever.
But, okay, what does that say about the culture? That we feel like there has to be some form of dishonesty even if it's just, just exaggeration in order to get anything sold.
So Cicero here is putting forward something that I don't, I don't think anyone in his day would have been any more, any, any less surprised by this than we are.
But it's just interesting that he puts it forward. And this is something that again, St. Ambrose is going to, is going to build on. But it's one of those things where here we have again, we keep coming to this is as far as you can get with natural reasoning, natural revelation without special revelation later.
And Cicero just goes that far because he's a clear thinker and a virtuous thinker and is trying to get to what the truly virtuous, truly good, truly beneficial in the long term course is.
[00:36:24] Chris Anadale: Excellent. Thank you, Katherine. That brings us to the end of this episode. You've been listening to the Cicero on Duties podcast with the scholars of the Ciceronian Society. I'm Chris Anadale. I've been joined for this episode by Josh Bowman and Catherine Bradshaw. If you'd like to learn more about our all of our programming to support a project of civic and cultural renewal, please check out the links in the description to this episode and visit our website at cicero.
Org. Thank you for listening.